[ Read Online The Wars of Afghanistan: Messianic Terrorism, Tribal Conflicts, and the Failures of Great Powers ☆ young-adult-science-fiction PDF ] by Peter Tomsen º An all encompassing book that covers nearly all of Afghanistan s modern history up to the later part of President Obama s first term in office At times a daunting read given the size of the book and the subject material contained within Peter Tomsen provides the reader with an in depth look at Afghanistan Those looking for a broader understanding of a country that has been at war in one stage or another for almost 40 years need look no further Tomsen charts the history of Afghanistan Post World War development, Soviet Invasion, Taliban rule, US Invasion and the impact the foreign policy of the worlds powers and Afghanistan s neighbours have had on it s history and development He places a lot of the blame for the struggles inside Afghanistan on Pakistan and this narrative carries many of his arguments for what he see s as what needs to change I have read many books on Afghanistan, probably than 50 Many of them are good, this is among the best The excruciating details of three years of diplomacy as the Russians pull out and the author, Peter Tomsen, tries to get the Americans, Pakistanis, and Afghans to work together will discourage any but the most devoted student I am teaching a class about Afghanistan at the local college so I plugged on until I finished this book The greatest shortcoming of this book other than the dense text that fills 700 plus pages with minor details of questionable relevance to today s reader is the almost total lack comments regarding illegal drugs Opium cultivation and processing into herion, drug smuggling, and the total corruption of the government and legal system in Afghanistan needs than the 10 or 12 sentences in this book.
As Ambassador And Special Envoy On Afghanistan From To , Peter Tomsen Has Had Close Relationships With Afghan Leaders And Has Dealt With Senior Taliban, Warlords, And Religious Leaders Involved In The Region S Conflicts Over The Last Two Decades Now Tomsen Draws On A Rich Trove Of Never Before Published Material To Shed New Light On The American Involvement In The Long And Continuing Afghan War This Book Offers A Deeply Informed Perspective On How Afghanistan S History As A Shatter Zone For Foreign Invaders And Its Tribal Society Have Shaped The Modern Afghan Narrative It Brings To Life The Appallingly Misinformed Secret Operations By Foreign Intelligence Agencies, Including The Soviet NKVD And KGB, The Pakistani ISI, And The CIAAmerican Policy Makers, Tomsen Argues, Still Do Not Understand Afghanistan Nor Do They Appreciate How The CIA S Covert Operations And The Pentagon S Military Strategy Have Strengthened Extremism In The Country At This Critical Time, He Shows How The US And The Coalition It Leads Can Assist The Region Back To Peace And Stability A superb, well written and dense book on the complex history of Afghanistan, history that has been ignored to the detriment of numerous foreign armies Afghanistan, as Tomsen shows, is pretty much a line on map with fictitious boundaries and a history of weak, ineffective and even irrelevant government and localized centers of power that naturally produce conflict.
The book is strong on Afghan culture and history, especially the tribal structures that make it so complex to outsiders At one point the story becomes personal as Tomsen recounts his own experience as a diplomat in the region.
It doesn t seem that Tomsen covered the rise of the Taliban in as much detail as I might have liked Still, he exposes the role of Pakistan in fomenting so much instability in the region by supporting radical Islamist factions that usually prove dangerous to Pakistan s own int A thorough accounting of the history of Afghanistan Although impressive in its breadth and depth, the storytelling drags in the middle I could not finish the book as it became terminally boring and a simple flood of names, dates and coups A clearly impressive scholarly work, but lacks the verve of other histories I have read.
This book is not a general history of Afghanistan Although it does briefly get into Afghanistan s ancient history in the early chapters, the book s real interest is in the events of the 20th and 21st centuries leading up to the present It s a little on the dry side and the flood of names, organizations, and ethnic groups can leave you a little confused That said, the book is still extremely informative and may very well transform your views on the subject.
What America did after the departure of Soviet Union from Afghanistan is nothing different from terrorism as well By using the excuse of war on terror, the underlying focus of the American state was also to avail the opportunity while it can to have a strong grip of the state that was already demolished and unstable Pakistan was nothing better too All the nations that contributed in the elimination of so called terrorism in Afghanistan just added fuel to fire while only keeping in mind what serves them best, completely ignoring the citizens welfare or safety The Pashtunwali code mentioned is a fact that should have been tackled with the extreme and circumspect intellect for the evolution of that savagery into something that we can call today a civilized or rather a humanly state Treating women like that, they need to have been subjected to severe punishmen Very informative gives a great background on the region and why the U.
S and others have gotten involved there It s also a very disturbing book because it exposes huge issues with our ability as a nation to implement foreign policy, or for that matter, come up with a good one in a given region we are involved in by listening to people who know My main take away from this book is that, as a country, there are huge dangers in ambiguous and half hearted foreign policies i.
e allowing Pakistan to guide our actions and support for Afghanistan, through which they duped us thoroughly for many years and inflamed the region for their own purposes which were in fact directly opposed to ours Also that it is very dangerous to enter into an area boldly but impulsively without a carefully considered long term geostrategic plan, relying instead on reactionary, tactical decisions to d
We never know the full truth behind current events Most people don t want to be bothered to discover it there are simply too many things going on in our lives to investigate each issue that passes before us in the news.
Nevertheless, for every issue there are people intimately involved, people who do know the truth and are perfectly placed to disclose to us what should determine our attitudes and actions They may not be able to speak the truth because of their position Speaking out can destroy a career or even a life Bradley Manning comes to mind.
Time changes circumstances The truth is no longer held hostage to policy, position or income when it becomes a matter of history Truth spills out often when it becomes irrelevant, yet as history it offers lessons for those willing to listen and for that reason I find history absorbing, particularly when it deals with issue Peter Tomsen s The Wars of Afghanistan is an incredibly thorough and insightful work, written by someone with a special expertise on the subject From 1989 to 1992, Tomsen served as George H.
W Bush s special envoy to the Afghan resistance, holding the rank of ambassador Working from Pakistan and Washington, he witnessed a shift in the political landscape following the Soviet withdrawal, culminating in the rise of the Taliban in September 1994, and their eventual ascension to power in 1996 In many ways, the author s chronicles of different Afghan, Pakistani, and Saudi figures in the 1980s and 90s is reminiscent of reading a book on the Mexican War a veritable who s who of people who would later become famous Abdul Haq, Ahmed Shah Masood, Gulbuddin Hekmatya